Ved Mehta image




Search for: 

Reviews

The Red Letters

Peeping at Papa

Sahara Times (New Delhi)

December 18, 2004

by Uma Mahadevan-Dasgupta

Review of The Red Letters by Ved Mehta


Ved Mehta's latest memoir recounts stories and letters from his father's love life.

Book extracts: Page 1 | Page 2 | Page 3 | Page 4 | Page 5 | Page 6

America-based writer Ved Mehta, who is seventy this year, was born in Lahore in 1934, and his family moved to India after Partition. He has been blind, caused by a childhood attack of cerebrospinal meningitis, since the age of four. He attended Balliol College, Oxford and Harvard University before beginning his writing career at the age of twenty. Thereafter, Mehta joined the staff of the New Yorker and remained there for thirty-three years. A recipient of several awards and honours (beginning with a Phi Beta Kappa in 1955, and Guggenheim and MacArthur Fellowships later in his career), he was written twenty-four books, which include accounts of modern India and Mahatma Gandhi. And, happily for us, he is still writing.

The Red Letters is the eleventh and final instalment of Mehta's Proust and Joyce-inspired autobiographical series, Continents of Exile, a series which includes Daddyji, Mamaji, and Remembering Mr Shawn's New Yorker, an account of Mehta's long career at that venerable publication (a career that lasted upto the advent of Tina Brown). Typically, in tracing the shifting landscapes of exile, he writes about the many diverse influences on his life: India, Pakistan, and Partition; then England, America, and the New Yorker — and occasionally but in a matter-of-fact way, the fact of his blindness. The first volumes in the series were about his father, a public health official in Indian government service, and his mother; about the Hindu family trying to enter the modern age at the cusp of the two centuries, nineteenth and twentieth; and about the circumstances that led up to his own blindness from childhood.

A slim volume, The Red Letters is a retelling of what Mehta calls his father's "enchanted period", his passionate relationship with a rich, very beautiful, westernised and unhappily married woman in Lahore in British India of the 1930s. Beginning with the discovery that his father had first met this woman, Rasil, when she was a naive shepherd girl in the Punjab mountains, Mehta learns of the chance meeting, years later, when his father is called in to treat a wealthy Lahore socialite, and discovers that the socialite is none other than his shepherd girl of the past, now trapped in an unhappy marriage and yet, for him, unchanged. Exploring the many layers and implications of the unfolding secrets of his parents' lives, Mehta confronts the tragic effects of the unhappy triangle on the central characters in the family drama, as well as on his own life.

This memoir is interesting not only for its insights into the complexities of family history, arranged marriages and the quest for love, but also for its honest descriptions of the writer's business of shaping a narrative out of such material. At first, trying to collaborate with his father on a sketchy account of a meeting with a pretty shepherd girl in the hills, against the backdrop of the misdeeds of little tyrannical princes and nawabs with dominion over their individual states, Mehta is not satisfied with the endings suggested by his father: "The endings were all unsatisfactory...In any event, the scenes jumped ahead thirty or forty years without giving any idea of what might have happened in the interim. I felt I had no choice but to abandon the project once and for all."

But then, gradually, he counters some new material. Sitting in the India International Centre in 1974 when he is in Delhi to research his Gandhi book, Mehta spends some evenings with his father, who once again brings up the topic of the unfinished story and its different possible endings. Listening to his father, Mehta realises that the hill encounter was, in fact, his father's own story: "His having slipped from conditional into indicative mood, and then from future into present tense, all but confirmed my surmise...I was trying my best to avoid admitting a certainty that was now on the edge of my consciousness."

And what of the Red Letters? They are the letters exchanged by Mehta's father and the woman who the young Ved knew as 'Auntie Rasil.' "Once I started reading them," says Mehta, "with the help of a trusted assistant, the curiosity I had felt somewhat in the face of their jarring reality...they gave me the dizzying sensation of being the voyeur that I had all along dreaded being. Their belonging to another time and generation did not take the edge off my discomfort." The letters of lovers are seldom interesting, and those of star-crossed lovers are even less so. Fortunately for us, Mehta is sensitive to the needs of his craft, and quotes from the letters with remarkable restraint.

Besides, despite the title of this volume the letters are not really his main subject in this memoir. In his typically lucid and elegant style, Mehta explains the dilemmas that he faced while writing this account, and how, in an effort to be honest both to the people in the story and to the story itself, he found his way through them: "I can't help but wonder if I am being self-serving or vengeful by using his most private memories as material for my writing. Anyway, by the nature of my vocation, I am ill-suited to keep secrets. In writing a series of books about myself and my family, among other things, with the title Continents of Exile, I have often been torn between loyalty to my family and loyalty to my craft, to which any kind of censorship is anathema. My father, who served as a source for some of the material, knew all too well how such conflicts tormented me. He also knew that I was always able to negotiate my way between the feelings of the people I was writing about and the demands of my craft — by disguising people and places, among other strategems. In any event, he, like me, sensed, even as he was confiding in me, that the story had a larger significance, something neither of us could yet verbalise, but which we imagined would far transcend his life — and maybe mine too."

That larger significance is the real subject of this honest and moving memoir.

Buy The Red Letters

The Red Letters book preview

Read other reviews of The Red Letters

Ved Mehta takes no responsibility for and makes no claim of accuracy for any information on this Web site that is not directly written by him.